Top 20 High Protein Dessert Recipes
This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
High protein desserts are one my specialties here at Flexible Feasts and I’ve made numerous of them throughout my years of cooking. I’ve narrowed down my list to these top 20 high protein dessert recipes that range from 6 to 64 grams of protein per serving, with calories between 90 and 830. I have made every one of these at least a few times, and the list only keeps the desserts that survived my kitchen. If your sweet tooth and your protein goal have been at odds, start here. This is the list where I keep my easy high protein desserts, and it’s the one I’d bookmark first.
How These Made the Cut
- Protein runs from 8 to 64 grams per serving, with half the list clearing 20 grams in a single dessert.
- The list covers a variety of styles of sweet fix: baked cakes, one-mug microwave treats, no-bake bowls, and frozen desserts.
- Cottage cheese, Greek yogurt, and protein powder do the protein work, so nothing here depends on an ingredient you have to special order.
- Added sugar stays low across the board. The sweetest picks get their sweetness from banana, maple syrup, or the protein powder itself.
- Every recipe is one I have made at least twice (tested and filmed), and the order follows my personal taste, so the picks at the top are the ones I actually reach for.
Who Should Bookmark This
- Anyone hitting a daily protein target who still wants dessert at the end of the day instead of skipping it.
- Meal preppers who want a treat ready to grab, since the brownies and banana pudding keep for the week.
- Anyone with a five minute window and a sweet tooth. The mug cake, the peanut butter mousse, and the banana pudding all fit.
- Families who want a dessert the whole table can eat. The carrot cake and lemon cake read like normal bakes until you check the macros.
- Anyone testing cottage cheese for the first time, since half the list uses it and none of it tastes like it does.
The Lineup
This list is ranked by my own personal taste, so the desserts at the top are the ones I actually recommend. If you want a safe first pick, start with one of the brownies and work your way down from there.
1. Protein Brownies
150 calories · 11g protein
These high protein brownies are the answer to a rich, fudgy chocolate dessert that fits right into your meal plan without derailing your progress. Each slice (9 total) has 11 grams of protein and only 2 grams of sugar (no added sugar) per square.
Get the Recipe
2. Cottage Cheese Brownies
90 calories · 9g protein
This is easily one of my favorite healthy desserts of all time. Each of these 4 ingredient brownies packs 9 grams of protein for just 90 calories, has no-added sugar and you would never guess the cottage cheese is in there.
Get the Recipe
3. Protein Carrot Cake
290 calories · 14g protein
This high protein carrot cake delivers 14 grams of protein per slice with just 290 calories, making it the kind of dessert that actually fits into a real meal plan. The oat flour base stays moist from Greek yogurt and applesauce, the frosting packs extra protein without the excess sugar, and every bite tastes like the kind of carrot cake you would order at a restaurant.
Get the Recipe
4. Greek Yogurt Lemon Cake
190 calories · 14g protein
This Greek Yogurt Lemon Cake packs 14 grams of protein into every slice while clocking in at just 190 calories. The whole recipe costs under $6 to make, and the only real equipment you need is a springform pan plus two bowls.
Get the Recipe
5. Chocolate Chip Banana Protein Mug Cake
300 calories · 15g protein
This high protein chocolate chip banana mug cake comes together in under 2 minutes and delivers the kind of warm, gooey comfort that usually takes way more effort than a busy weeknight allows. One mug, one spoon, and 60 seconds in the microwave is all it takes for a snack or dessert treat that has 15 grams of protein.
Get the Recipe
6. Low Carb Protein Chocolate Cake Bites
110 calories · 8g protein
Each of these low carb protein chocolate cake bites packs 8 grams of protein with just 110 calories, making them a genuinely satisfying treat that fits into any flexible diet plan. They bake in 20 minutes at 350 degrees, then cool into dense little squares that taste more like dessert than a health food.
Get the Recipe
7. Protein Chocolate Ramekin Cakes
280 calories · 30g protein
Each of these mini cakes packs 30 grams of protein, which is pretty rare for a dessert that actually tastes like something you’d indulge in. These Protein Chocolate Ramekin Cakes bake in individual portions, so you get a proper dessert experience without the temptation of eating the whole batch in one sitting.
Get the Recipe
8. Protein Cinnamon Rolls
280 calories · 18g protein
Almond flour dough, a cinnamon butter filling, and a protein glaze that sets firm instead of melting into a puddle. Each roll has 18 grams of protein, and the dental floss cutting trick keeps every piece shaped like the real thing.
Get the Recipe
9. Apple Cinnamon Protein Donut Holes
140 calories · 6g protein
Six grams of protein per piece in a treat that tastes like the cinnamon sugar version from the bakery. The air fryer gets the whole batch done in under 30 minutes, which is exactly what you want when the craving hits before you have time to plan a meal.
Get the Recipe
10. Protein Lemon Bars
230 calories · 12g protein
A nutty almond flour crust under a tangy Greek yogurt filling with 12 grams of protein per bar and just 4 grams of carbs. They slice into clean little squares, which is why I make a full pan and ration them out of the fridge through the week.
Get the Recipe
11. Cottage Cheese Chocolate Mousse
430 calories · 25g protein
This cottage cheese chocolate mousse is my most popular YouTube video with over 100k views and it’s clear why it’s so popular. It’s the perfect high-protein dessert for anyone who wants something creamy and indulgent while still fitting into a balanced eating plan.
Get the Recipe
12. Cottage Cheese Peanut Butter Mousse
310 calories · 21g protein
Most people think of cottage cheese for savory dishes, but blend it smooth and it turns into the creamiest mousse base you can get. This cottage cheese peanut butter mousse takes five minutes and gives you 21 grams of protein per serving, making it one of the easiest high-protein desserts around.
Get the Recipe
13. Protein Peanut Butter Cups
340 calories · 20g protein
Each of these little peanut butter cups packs 20 grams of protein with just 2 grams of sugar (no-added sugar). The melted peanut butter base mixed with vanilla whey protein creates a soft center that gets drizzled with a thin layer of sugar-free chocolate.
Get the Recipe
14. Cottage Cheese Ice Cream
280 calories · 16g protein
This high protein cottage cheese ice cream delivers 16 grams of protein per serving while tasting every bit like the real creamy, indulgent dessert. The entire base comes together in about 5 minutes of blending, then you just freeze it and wait.
Get the Recipe
15. Protein Vanilla Gelato
520 calories · 64g protein
This protein vanilla gelato is a great alternative to the protein ice cream recipes that use a frozen banana or an ice cream maker (nothing wrong with either by the way.) The chilled Greek yogurt gives it that thick, creamy texture you expect from real gelato, and the vanilla protein powder does most of the flavor work so you barely taste the supplement at all. If you want another protein ice cream recipe that doesn’t use bananas or an ice cream maker, my Cottage Cheese Ice Cream is another solid option.
Get the Recipe
16. Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Protein Nice Cream
830 calories · 61g protein
This Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Nice Cream packs 61 grams of protein into a thick, creamy frozen treat that takes less than five minutes to make. What’s nice about it compared to Cottage Cheese Ice Cream is you skip the dairy entirely.
Get the Recipe
17. Protein Peanut Butter Cookie Dough
400 calories · 48g protein
This protein peanut butter cookie dough packs 48 grams of protein into a single no-bake bowl that tastes like dessert but fuels like a meal. It takes four ingredients, one bowl, and ten minutes in the fridge to come together.
Get the Recipe
18. Cottage Cheese Banana Pudding
400 calories · 29g protein
This high-protein cottage cheese banana pudding delivers 29 grams of protein in one creamy, dessert-like serving that takes just five minutes to blend. Maple syrup and cinnamon turn simple ingredients into something that tastes like a treat from a bakery, not a meal prep container.
Get the Recipe
19. Cottage Cheese Mini Cheesecakes
130 calories · 14g protein
Each of these cottage cheese mini cheesecakes delivers 14 grams of protein with just 130 calories. The blender method makes them incredibly smooth with no cottage cheese aftertaste, and you only need six simple ingredients to pull them off.
Get the Recipe
20. Microwave Protein Cheesecake
480 calories · 39g protein
This microwave protein cheesecake packs 39 grams of protein into a dessert that actually tastes like the real thing. It comes together in one bowl, takes less than three minutes in the microwave, and sets up firm enough to eat with a spoon.
Get the RecipeQuick Comparison
| Recipe | Calories | Protein |
|---|---|---|
| Protein Brownies | 150 | 11g |
| Cottage Cheese Brownies | 90 | 9g |
| Protein Carrot Cake | 290 | 14g |
| Greek Yogurt Lemon Cake | 190 | 14g |
| Chocolate Chip Banana Protein Mug Cake | 300 | 15g |
| Low Carb Protein Chocolate Cake Bites | 110 | 8g |
| Protein Chocolate Ramekin Cakes | 280 | 30g |
| Protein Cinnamon Rolls | 280 | 18g |
| Apple Cinnamon Protein Donut Holes | 140 | 6g |
| Protein Lemon Bars | 230 | 12g |
| Cottage Cheese Chocolate Mousse | 430 | 25g |
| Cottage Cheese Peanut Butter Mousse | 310 | 21g |
| Protein Peanut Butter Cups | 340 | 20g |
| Cottage Cheese Ice Cream | 280 | 16g |
| Protein Vanilla Gelato | 520 | 64g |
| Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Protein Nice Cream | 830 | 61g |
| Protein Peanut Butter Cookie Dough | 400 | 48g |
| Cottage Cheese Banana Pudding | 400 | 29g |
| Cottage Cheese Mini Cheesecakes | 130 | 14g |
| Microwave Protein Cheesecake | 480 | 39g |
Before You Start Cooking
-
Portion the frozen and no-bake picks
Freeze the mousse and cookie dough in single servings right after they set. Grabbing one from the freezer is easier than digging into the pan, and it keeps the portion honest.
-
Batch the make-ahead bakes
The brownies and cake bites keep well in the fridge, so one afternoon of baking covers most of your week.
-
Match the fix to the craving
Use the Quick Comparison table to shop by craving. Warm and fudgy goes to the brownies or mug cake, creamy and cold goes to the mousse or ice cream, and grab-and-go goes to the peanut butter cups and cookie dough. If you only have time for one protein desserts recipe this week, the mug cake at under 2 minutes and the microwave cheesecake at under 3 are the fastest starts.
-
Blend cottage cheese until it is fully smooth
Lumps are what give cottage cheese desserts away. Blend the mousse and pudding bases a little longer than feels necessary, then chill them for at least an hour before serving.
-
Push the protein up when you need it
Many of these take an extra scoop of protein powder without falling apart, which is the easiest way to move a 15 gram treat into the 20s.
FAQs
-
Which high protein dessert recipe has the most protein?
The Protein Vanilla Gelato leads the list at 64 grams per serving, with the Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Protein Nice Cream close behind at 61 grams and the Protein Peanut Butter Cookie Dough at 48 grams.
-
What is the lowest calorie high protein dessert?
The Cottage Cheese Brownies are the lightest at 90 calories with 9 grams of protein. The Low Carb Protein Chocolate Cake Bites come in at 110 calories with 8 grams, and the Cottage Cheese Mini Cheesecakes at 130 calories with 14 grams. If you’ve been looking for high protein low calorie desserts, these three are the place to start. For high protein dessert recipes for weight loss, the mini cheesecakes are one of the strongest protein per calorie picks on the whole list at 14 grams in 130.
-
Can I meal prep high protein desserts?
Several are built for it. The brownies and cake bites keep in the fridge or freezer for the week, the banana pudding holds up in the fridge for a few days, and the frozen treats keep until you are ready for them.
-
Do high protein desserts taste like protein powder?
Most of these hide the powder well. The brownies, mug cake, and ramekin cakes bake it into chocolate, while the mousse and banana pudding lean on cottage cheese and Greek yogurt, which blend completely smooth. When a powder note does show up, chocolate and peanut butter are the easiest flavors to mask it with.
-
What high protein dessert can I make in under 10 minutes?
Five on this list do. The Chocolate Chip Banana Protein Mug Cake takes under 2 minutes, the Microwave Protein Cheesecake under 3, the Cottage Cheese Peanut Butter Mousse about 5, the Cottage Cheese Banana Pudding about 5, and the nice cream under 5.
-
How many of these use cottage cheese?
Six of the 20 start with blended cottage cheese, from the brownies and mini cheesecakes to the mousse, pudding, and ice cream picks. If you want more high protein cottage cheese dessert recipes in that style, they live on my cottage cheese recipes list.
